Speculation about a potential settlement in the SEC vs. Ripple case has intensified recently. Users on X (formerly Twitter) have expressed hope for a resolution that could clarify XRP’s security status. However, former SEC lawyer Marc Fagel quickly debunked these rumors, labeling them as “fake news.” He emphasized that the discussions referenced by users relate to a separate investor class action lawsuit, not the ongoing SEC case against Ripple.
Legal Context of the Case
The ongoing legal battle began in December 2020, with Ripple facing scrutiny over its sales of XRP. Recently, Judge Hamilton suggested that both parties might explore “alternative resolutions.” This comment sparked optimism among some investors regarding a potential settlement. Nevertheless, Fagel pointed out that the SEC has held numerous meetings since the lawsuit’s inception, and none have resulted in a settlement.
Ripple’s chief legal officer, Stuart Alderoty, stated that the SEC cannot introduce new evidence at this stage of the appeal. He criticized the SEC for creating confusion surrounding the case. Ripple recently filed its response in the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, outlining its arguments for why certain XRP sales should not be classified as securities.
Financial Implications
The SEC is currently seeking a penalty of $102.6 million against Ripple, significantly lower than its initial demand of nearly $2 billion. Ripple has proposed limiting this penalty to $10 million, citing precedents from other cases. Legal experts speculate that Judge Torres may award a penalty below $25 million, which would be a favorable outcome for Ripple.
Despite these legal challenges, XRP’s price has remained relatively stable around 52 cents. Over the past month, however, it has dropped approximately 17%. Analysts note that while no specific news directly correlates with this price movement, speculation about a settlement may have influenced market sentiment.
Future Developments
As both parties await a ruling from Judge Torres regarding remedies and penalties, the next steps in this legal saga could take months. The appeals process may not see significant movement until January 2025. Ripple aims to clarify critical legal questions surrounding investment contracts under the Securities Act of 1933.
In summary, while rumors of a settlement circulate, they lack substantial evidence. The ongoing legal proceedings will play a crucial role in determining XRP’s future and regulatory status in the cryptocurrency market.
Read Also: Ripple’s Legal Battle Intensifies as SEC Maintains XRP is a Security